Top 10 Best Baby Crib Mattresses in 2023 Reviews

Last updated on January 15, 2023

Having a safe and sound slumber is healthy for toddlers and babies. It has been a dream for many parents to get the best crib mattresses for their kids. Sometimes, the selection becomes difficult, and this sees you fall for substandard products.

If you want the best baby crib mattress from the market, then consider the one with high-quality construction. The cribs need to be breathable, easy to clean, and most importantly, one that meets the safety standards for the baby’s health.

Often, buyers get confused with varieties of baby crib mattresses on the market. Our goal is to get you a straightforward way in which you will select a mattress that boosts your baby’s development and growth. In line with this, we introduce you to the top ten Best Baby Crib Mattresses Reviews. We hope you will find this information resourceful when selecting and making your purchase.

10. Milliard Crib Mattress

Milliard Crib Mattress

Check Price on Amazon

This exclusive mattress features a dual comfort system whereby the hard side is ideal for infants while the soft side works well for toddlers. Milliard Crib Mattress originates from high-quality materials for durability. The artistry is also on point as all the stitches feature excellent finishes. The mattress looks amazing.

Your toddlers sleeping postures are kept in the correct place as the mattress features supporting foam layer and contouring memory foam layer. Equally important, this mattress meets and exceeds the US quality standards and hence safe for your kids.


  • Features memory foam to keep toddlers deep asleep
  • Dual comfort system, for multiuse
  • Easy to clean
  • Meet quality standards for the US


  • Not waterproof

9. Newton Baby Mini Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

Newton Baby Mini Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

Check Price on Amazon

Babies who roll over at night need this mattress. It is breathable and won’t cause suffocation to your baby. The Newton Baby Mini Crib Mattress comes from quality materials which are hypoallergenic, non-toxic, and this will keep your toddler safe throughout the mattress lifetime. Another important thing is the quality which ensures your mattress meets the manufacturing safety standard for toddler’s safety. In addition to this, the temperature control fabric eliminates the sweaty nights that might cause discomfort to your toddler.

Lastly, this model is home washable and won’t stress you as the fabric is smooth and easy to dry.


  • Ideal for toddlers and infants
  • Breathable and temperature regulating
  • Mini crib and hence fits toddlers bed
  • Non-toxic therefore safe for the toddlers


  • Corners are too soft

8. Organic Cotton Waterproof Fitted Crib Pad

Organic Cotton Waterproof Fitted Crib Pad

Check Price on Amazon

When you want a crib mattress for your toddler, then look no further as the best available deal is the Organic Cotton Waterproof Fitted Crib Pad. It comes from quality non-toxic materials for durability. You will, therefore, get the value for the money. At the same time, your kid’s safety is guaranteed as t5he mattress features breathable fabric, and this won’t suffocate your toddler.

Furthermore, this crib mattress fits as described, and for this reason, you won’t get troubles with stretching corners. It also guarantees you zero liquid penetration and this will work well in case of spills and will, therefore, become easy to clean any mess.

Finally, this model comes with four-layer protection to see your toddler safe four times than the standard crib mattresses on the market.


  • Durable construction
  • Waterproof type
  • Non-toxic hence healthier for the baby
  • Fits perfectly on the bed


  • Features some polyester

7. Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress

Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress

Check Price on Amazon

The Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress is here for parents who value quality. It comes from quality materials that are breathable and durable. This will see your toddler enjoy some peaceful sleep through the night.

The softcover adds up as a waterproof type which is easy to remove and clean the mattress. Since it’s a lightweight mattress, you will find it easy to move from place to place. Its durability ensures that your toddler grows with it and hence a great deal to save your money.

For added safety standard, you will have the confidence to purchase this mattress for your kids as it is GreenGuard Gold certified.


  • Durable construction
  • Safe for the kids as it’s certified
  • Features a water-resistant cover
  • Easy to clean fabric


  • The mattress doesn’t expand fully

6. American Baby Company

American Baby Company

Check Price on Amazon

The American Baby Company toddler mattress is designed to give you the best results. For instance, your toddler will get the best comfort from the three layers on this mattress. These layers include; the top layer made from organic cotton, a mid-layer made from breathable polyester and the back layer made from organic cotton.

The waterproof cover is soft and will protect your mattress as well as the baby. More so, the surface will be easy to clean and dry, and this eliminates the stress that comes with cleaning. Apart from the waterproof cover, this mattress comes with a quiet operation as the soft materials used in its construction eliminate the crinkling noises. This gives the toddler peace of mind while sleeping.


  • Waterproof cover for safety
  • Meets the quality assurance standards in the US
  • Quiet type and no crinkling sounds
  • Features three layers for comfort


  • Shrinks a lot

5. Dream On Me 3″ Playard Mattress

Dream On Me 3

Check Price on Amazon

Dream On Me has an exceptional design for your child’s safety. It’s ideal for six months and above baby. You will love the USA quality as it comes from quality materials for durability. The model has been certified, and this gives it an upper hand in the market.

When it comes to safety, this mattress is waterproof and antibacterial. It’s, therefore, great for your baby’s health. Besides, the mattress has passed the inflammability tests and hence a sure way to get your kid safe.

Lastly, this beautiful mattress for your toddlers comes with a thirty-day warranty, and this gives you time to observe the progress and monitor how your toddler responds to it.


  • Durable construction for lifetime use
  • Easy to clean
  • Waterproof design
  • Passed the anti-inflammatory tests


  • Its very firm

4. Official Amazon Exclusive NapYou Dual Comfort Crib Mattress

Official Amazon Exclusive NapYou Dual Comfort Crib Mattress

Check Price on Amazon

The NapYou Dual Comfort Crib Mattress comes with a dual version for both the toddlers and the infants. The soft side is designed for the toddler’s whereas the firm side works well for the infants. This ensures your baby grows with the mattress and hence saving you the future purchases.

The supportive and contouring layers boost your toddlers and infant sleep, and this keeps them comfortable through the night. Moreover, you will fall in love with the 100% waterproof cover that makes it easy for you to clean the child’s mess.


  • Mattress certified for safe use
  • Durable for long-term use
  • Features dual operation
  • Waterproof cover hence easy to clean


  • Too soft for the newborn

3. Big Oshi Portable/Mini Crib Mattress

Big Oshi Portable/Mini Crib Mattress

Check Price on Amazon

If you have a standard size portable mini crib, then this Big Oshi Portable/Mini Crib Mattress is your ideal mattress to fit correctly. It’s thick and comfortable and measures 38 “x24″ x3”. This ensures your baby sleeps comfortably through the night. It comes from high-quality materials hence durable and safe for the toddler.

The waterproof cover has made the cleaning quite comfortable and will eliminate the stress that comes with other types of covers. You will also get a positive impression from the way it ships fast and the kind of packaging done. Above all, the prices are attractive compared to the exemplary quality.


  • Durable construction
  • Waterproof cover for easy cleaning
  • Fits standard sized cribs
  • The prices are soothing


  • It’s hard

2. Delta Children Twinkle Stars

Delta Children Twinkle Stars

Check Price on Amazon

Delta Children Twinkle Stars is a three-inch portable crib mattress ideal for your toddler. It has a fiber core to make it firm and comfortable to support your toddler. The fact that this mattress constructs form non-toxic materials makes it safe for your toddler, and this is the goal for every parent.

You will also love the waterproof design that makes the mattress even easy to clean whenever the child messes on it. In addition to this, the mattress has safety certifications from GreenGuard, and this gives you the confidence to trust the mattress.

Finally, this mattress is made in the USA and comes with a one year warranty for you to use it in peace.


  • Comes from quality materials hence durable
  • Waterproof thus easy to clean
  • Certified by GreenGuard
  • Fits perfectly to mini cribs


  • The mattress is short

1. Moonlight Slumber Mini Crib Mattress

Moonlight Slumber Mini Crib Mattress

Check Price on Amazon

If you want an extra firm mattress for infants and a splash one for toddlers, then this Moonlight Slumber Mini Crib Mattress will meet your requirements. It’s among the few types with high-quality certification worldwide. For instance, this model is UL certified by Green guard and CertiPUR-US. This means that the quality is excellent.

This model has a waterproof cover and also resistant to chemical s and other foreign materials. This makes it easy to wash in case of any mess. More so, you get to use it fast as it dries quickly. This mattress also features cool gel memory foam which keeps the kid feeling well. This results in great sleep that promotes the child’s growth and development.


  • Dual mattress for toddlers and infants
  • Breathable type
  • Non-toxic and certified
  • Waterproof cover for easy cleaning


  • Very light

How to choose the best Baby Crib Mattress

The market has varieties of these mattresses, and this might be a challenge when you are looking for the best deal with exemplary quality. Well, here are a few considerations before you decide to buy the mattress

Types of crib mattresses

We have three types, namely; coil crib mattress, which is made with coil and reduces the risk of sudden infant death. This is followed by the foam crib mattresses, which are lightweight and soft for toddler’s safety. Lastly, we have the double-sided which can be used during infancy through to toddler. Choose the one that meets your requirements.

Waterproof types

If you get a waterproof model, then cleaning will be an easy task as the mess doesn’t penetrate through. It also saves your mattress form developing molds, which would reduce the durability of the mattress.


We have the crib mattresses that come with water-resistant covers, and this is the best choice for you. Others come with several layers, and this will see you decide on which model you need, especially for your cleaning needs. You have the option of selecting the types with waterproof covers for easy cleaning and durability.

Materials used

Most of the crib mattresses are made from organic materials. However, we have other types that come from polymers, and these are a bit unhealthy for the child. Ensure the materials are safe for the child. The safety comes with certification by the quality assurance firms.

Materials used in construction also matter when it comes to durability. Therefore, get the durable model to match your investment.

Size of the mattress

Different sizes are available. Check your cribs measurement before you decide to buy. We have the mattresses that fit all standard cribs, and these are some of the areas you need to be attentive.


Different types come with various rates, and this is a crucial area when it comes to your budget. Get the one that meets your budgetary requirements. Prices depend on the materials used, safety features included as well as the ease of use.

Compliance standards

When toddlers’ mattresses meet the safety standards after rigorous testing, then it’s suitable for the babies. Ensure the type is certified and great for the toddlers and infants. And, it should meet the cribs safety standards.


The Best Baby Crib Mattresses reviews have all that you need for your toddler’s safety, growth, and development. As we walked through this review: our key focus was on getting you the best crib mattress for your baby, so that you can relax while the mattress keeps your baby comfortable.

We have also highlighted a few areas you need to consider before making any purchase. This will ensure you get the best deal that meets your requirements. At the same time, you will get quality at an affordable price. With this in mind, go ahead and purchase one or more today and benefit from great services and excellent quality. You won’t regret the purchase.

Related posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *